HumanitiesWeb.org - Gallery - Themes in Art
HumanitiesWeb HumanitiesWeb
WelcomeHistoryLiteratureArtMusicPhilosophyResourcesHelp
Periods Alphabetically Nationality Topics Themes Medium Glossary
pixel

Art
Sort by Period
Sort Alphabetically
Sort by Nationality
Topics
Themes in Art
Medium
Glossary

Search

Get Your Degree!

Find schools and get information on the program that’s right for you.

Powered by Campus Explorer

& etc
FEEDBACK

(C)1998-2012
All Rights Reserved.

Site last updated
28 October, 2012
Real Time Analytics

Historical Paintings

Painters today often complain that they've been reduced to servants of interior decorators. And it's a valid complaint, except among those artists only too willing, for a price, to fulfil the need to match size, style, shape, and colours with couch and carpet. It might surprise artists on all sides of the issue to know there's nothing new in all this. As far back as the Renaissance, painters were asked by wealthy patrons to cater - in the subject of their work, at least if not size and colour - to its location within their new ducal palaces to certain expected norms. Scenes with philosophers were expected in studies; feast scenes went into dining rooms (last suppers if they were monastery dining rooms). Paintings of battles or great pomp and ceremony were required for reception rooms and, naturally, semi-erotic scenes of Greek gods pursuing nymphs and maidens were all important for the bedroom. What's an artist to do?

Most of those we recall today happily complied. Those who didn't mostly don't get recalled. In general, except for some religious scenes for perhaps the chapel, and the obligatory mythology for the bedroom, this early form of interior decorating amounted to the then relatively new genre of history painting. Which was fine for the first hundred years or so, but as the number of frescoed walls kept growing, the number of historic anecdotes to fill them did not. I mean, what's a rich young ruler to do? If the neighbours on one side have Claude's Seaport with the Embarkation of the Queen of Sheba (1648) and the neighbours on the other side have Poussin's Et in Arcadia Ergo (1639), the last thing you want in your grand salon is more of the same. But then again, it can't be too different. Maybe that new guy, Guercino, might be able to come up with something?

Guercino came up with Hersilia Separating Romulus from Tacitus (1645) which might go a long way in explaining why few of us recall Guercino. In other words, the more history painting that gets done, the harder it is to come up with history that needs to be done. By the eighteenth century, would-be history painters were reduced to painting what we'd call now historic trivia - some of their scenes so trivial that art scholars today are reduced to outright speculation as to what they depict, much less what they mean. History painting became such a prestigious striving for artists that they were reduced to combing through contemporary literature, Shakespeare and the like for even second-hand accounts from which to create new work. Just about anything would do, so long as it hadn't already been done to death, and it wasn't so mundane as to look like genre.

Of course, history tried to supply its legions of history-painting artists as best it could. The eighteenth and nineteenth centuries were both filled with all manner of wars, skulduggery, political scandals, beheadings, firing squads, burnings, and other dramatic events - enough to fill volumes of history books, but not enough to sate the appetites of those who, in effect, illustrated them. Jean-Auguste Ingres went so far as to turn to Vasari's Lives of the Most Excellent Painters, Sculptors, and Architects (kind of an early ArtyFacts) in search of subject matter. In 1812, he painted Raphael and La Fornarina, becoming the first history painter in history to paint another history painter. The work depicts the dashing young artist with the love of his life (a baker's daughter) on his knee, his attention not upon his lovely bride-to-be (he died mysteriously before they could be wed), but looking back over his shoulder at the drawn image of her on his easel - an artist to the end.

As early American artists were prone to do, painters such a Benjamin West and John Vanderlyn went to Europe to learn the technical principles of history painting. In so doing, they turned to the history of their own continent, as in West's The Death of General Wolfe (1770) or Vanderlyn's The Murder of Jane McCrea (1804). And while Wolfe's depiction might fall well within the European tradition, Vanderlyn's pleading, screaming white woman about to be scalped by two stripling Native-Americans (based upon Greek models of course) so they could sell her tresses to the English strikes us as abhorrently violent, not to mention terribly inconsequential. Blessedly, there was never much market for history painting in this country, and anyway, much of what was done gravitated toward tired, static, but quite civilised group portraits depicting the signing of peace treaties and other historic documents.

For all its much vaunted, thematic, high (and low) mindedness in the past, fortunately, history painting today is even "deader" than genre. I use the word "fortunately" because, quite frankly, artists have never been very good at this sort of thing. Today we have news photos and taped instant replays flashed on TV and the Internet within mere seconds of the event, some of which are destined to become the modern equivalent of history painting. And as much as we may bemoan the various slants and outright distortion of the news by those charged with documenting it, visually at least, that which passes for historic art today is a far cry more accurate (and artistic) than the storybook art that passed for history ages ago.

contributed by Lane, Jim


22 January 2001

Related Artists Related Articles
Benjamin West
Jacques-Louis David
John Trumbull
Albrecht Altdorfer
Nicolas Poussin
Ernest Meissonier
American History Painting
An American van Gogh?
American History Painters
American History Painting
The Rise of Genre in American Painting
X Marks the Spot
Painting in Tumultous Times
Art Changes History
Doing His Homework
George Catlin
Journalistic/Propagandist Painting
American History Painters
American History Painting
An American van Gogh?
Benjamin West
"The Grand Manner" Comes to America
A Burial at Ornans
Constantino Brumidi
Sir David Wilkie
  
Works  
A Converted British Family Sheltering a Christian Missionary from the Persecution of the Druids (William Holman Hunt)
A Huguenot on St Bartolomew's Day (Sir John Everett Millais)
Agrippina Landing at Brindisium with the Ashes of Germanicus (Gavin Hamilton)
Cleopatra Testing Poisons on Condemned Prisoners (Alexandre Cabanel)
Constantine's Dream (Piero della Francesca)
Death of Sardanapalus (Eugène Delacroix)
Death of Sophonisba (Giovanni Battista Pittoni)
Democritus (Antoine Coypel)
Information: (Ernest Meissonier)
Joan of Arc in Prison (Howard Pyle)
Louis XIV reçoit l'ambassadeur de Perse (Antoine Coypel)
Marat Assassinated (Jacques-Louis David)
Massacre at Chios (Eugène Delacroix)
Merriamne Leaving the Judgement Seat of Herod (John William Waterhouse)
Napoleon Bonaparte on Arcole Bridge on 17 November 1796 (Baron Antoine-Jean Gros)
Napoleon in the Pesthouse at Jaffa (Baron Antoine-Jean Gros)
Napoleon on the Battlefield of Eylau on 9 February 1807 (Baron Antoine-Jean Gros)
Nebuchadnezzar (William Blake)
Ojibway Indian Spearing the Maskenozha (Frank E. Schoonover)
Phryné before the Areopagus (Jean Léon Gérôme)
Prison Scene (Francisco José de Goya Y Lucientes)
Raphael and the Fornarina (Jean-Auguste-Dominique Ingres)
Semiramis Receives the Message of the Babylonion Revolt (Anton Raphael Mengs)
The 28th July: Liberty Leading the People (Eugène Delacroix)
The Banquet of Cleopatra (Giambattista Tiepolo)
The Battle between Heraclius and Chosroes (Piero della Francesca)
The Battle of Alexander (Albrecht Altdorfer)
The Bucentaur Departs for the Lido on Ascension Day (Francesco Guardi)
The Burning of the Hötel-Dieu during the Night of 29-30 December 1772 (Hubert Robert)
The Continence of Scipio (François le Moyne)
The Coronation of Charlemagne (Raffaello Sanzio (Raphael))
The Death of General Wolfe (Benjamin West)
The Death of Major Pierson on the 6th of January of 1781 (John Singleton Copley)
The Death of Socrates (Jacques-Louis David)
The Doge in the Bucentaur at San Nicolo di Lido on Ascension Day (Francesco Guardi)
The Doge of Venice goes to the Salute on 21 November to Commemorate the End of the Plague of 1630 (Francesco Guardi)
The Esquilache Riots (Francisco José de Goya Y Lucientes)
The Execution (Edouard Manet)
The Family of Darius before Alexander (Paolo Caliari (Veronese))
The Fatal Wounding of Sir Philip Sidney (Benjamin West)
The French Campaign (Ernest Meissonier)
The Lictors Bring to Brutus the Bodies of His Sons (Jacques-Louis David)
The Oath of Brutus (Gavin Hamilton)
The Oath of the Horatii (Jacques-Louis David)
The Raft of the Medusa (Jean Louis André Théodore Géricault)
The Red Cross Knight (John Singleton Copley)
The Roses of Heliogabalus (Sir Lawrence Alma-Tadema)
The School of Athens (Raffaello Sanzio (Raphael))
The Seat of Justice in the Parliament of Paris (Nicolas Lancret)
The Siege of Paris (Ernest Meissonier)
The South Sea Scheme (William Hogarth)
The Suicide of Lucretia (Albrecht Dürer)
The Surrender of Breda (Diego Velázquez)
The Third of May, 1808 (Francisco José de Goya Y Lucientes)
The Women of Amphissa (Sir Lawrence Alma-Tadema)
Watson and the Shark (John Singleton Copley)
 

Personae

Terms Defined

Referenced Works